Why Back Surgery Sometimes Fails: Understanding and Treating Failed Back Surgery Syndrome
The Kentucky Pain Reversal ShowOctober 22, 2026x
11
00:24:4116.98 MB

Why Back Surgery Sometimes Fails: Understanding and Treating Failed Back Surgery Syndrome



Welcome back to the Kentucky Pain Reversal Show. In today’s episode, we take a closer look at a misunderstood and all-too-common reality for many people living with persistent back pain: failed back surgery syndrome. Dr. Ajith Nair joins Jamie to explain why even a technically perfect back surgery can leave patients suffering, the surprising science behind ongoing pain after surgery, and why repeat operations are rarely the answer. We’ll dive into real stories from the front lines of pain management, explore the human toll of chronic pain, and most importantly, discuss cutting-edge options that move beyond pills and unnecessary surgeries. If you or someone you love is struggling with pain after back surgery, this episode is for you. There is hope and there are answers right here in Kentucky.

00:00 Explaining the laminectomy process

06:04 Understanding sciatica and herniated discs

07:48 Understanding Chronic Back Pain

12:00 Discussing chronic pain solutions

16:11 Post-surgery recovery timeline

20:23 Tapering opioids for pain pump trial

23:34 Alternative pain management strategies

24:58 Ending thoughts on persistent pain


When Surgery Doesn’t End the Pain: Insights on Failed Back Surgery Syndrome

For countless Kentuckians, back surgery offers hope the promise that this time, the pain that shadows every daily task will finally end. Yet, for many, surgical “success” is not the end of their struggle. If you’ve ever left the operating room only to realize your pain is still with you or even worse this episode of the Kentucky Pain Reversal Show is for you.

In this episode, Dr. Ajith Nair turns the spotlight from medical tools to real people suffering after back surgery, unraveling the misunderstood and often-overlooked condition known as Failed Back Surgery Syndrome (FBSS).

What is Failed Back Surgery Syndrome (FBSS)?

Dr. Ajith Nair describes FBSS also known as post-laminectomy pain syndrome as persistent pain after back surgery, often following procedures like the removal of herniated discs. While surgery may initially bring relief, pain often returns with a vengeance. The culprit: scar tissue formation. After part of the spine called the lamina is removed, the body heals over the area with scar tissue, which can adhere to sensitive nerve roots and recreate (or even worsen) the pain that drove the patient to surgery in the first place 03:34.

Unfortunately, the numbers are significant: studies suggest that anywhere from 8% to 20% of back surgery patients develop FBSS 05:07. In practices like Dr. Ajith Nair’s, the percentage is higher simply because he sees so many people desperate for relief after multiple surgeries.

Why Does Surgery Sometimes Fail to Fix the Pain?

A key insight from Dr. Ajith Nair is that fixing anatomy does not always fix pain 05:48. Pain is complicated. It involves structural problems, of course, but also nerves, soft tissue, and even the ways our brains process injury.

Sometimes, the pain sticks around because damaged nerves have formed new pain circuits a process called central sensitization. Even after surgery removes physical pressure from the nerves, these circuits can keep firing, leading to persistent pain 07:34. Other times, muscle or ligament damage, loss of disc height, or pain from nearby spine joints (facet joints) is to blame.

The Human Toll: What Do Patients Experience?

Patients who end up in Dr. Ajith Nair’s office are often at their wits’ end on high doses of pain medications, unable to work, their lives shadowed by relentless pain and depression 10:24. Dr. Ajith Nair emphasizes the importance of listening: “I give them enough time to express themselves because I think that’s part of healing too” 11:02. Addressing both the physical and psychological sides of pain is crucial.

Why More Surgery Is Rarely the Answer

The instinct both for patients and surgeons is to try “fixing” the pain with another operation. But as Dr. Ajith Nair explains, repeat surgeries usually backfire, leading to more scar tissue and even more pain 14:32. Once multiple surgeries have altered spinal anatomy, interventions like medication pumps or nerve stimulators become far more effective than returning to the operating table.

A Message of Hope and Practical Advice

If you’re still hurting after surgery, don’t lose hope. Dr. Ajith Nair urges patients to seek a pain specialist if their pain hasn’t improved 3-4 months after surgery not to give up, and not to accept that “nothing more can be done” 17:12. Advanced pain management tools, like spinal cord stimulators, pain pumps, and peripheral nerve stimulators, offer alternatives to endless pills or repeat surgeries.

Reducing pain medication is a pillar of Dr. Ajith Nair’s mission. Pills have their place, but less can be more clearing the mind and enabling quality of life, exercise, and true recovery 23:34.

Final Takeaway

If you’ve had back surgery and still hurt, you are not imagining things, you are not a failure, and you are not alone 25:19. There is a path forward. Surgery may not have ended your pain, but a different kind of answer and a different kind of doctor may make all the difference.

If you or someone you love is stuck in post-surgical pain, remember: there are options, and hope is very much alive in Kentucky.


Podcast Website - https://thekentuckypainreversal.com/

Dr. Ajith Nair Clinic - https://kentuckianapainspecialists.com/

Media Partner - https://tophealth.care/


SPEAKER_01

I remember treating a ninety-one year old patient who had six back surgeries, and she was taking a bucket load of fentanyl, and despite that she had chronic intractable pain. We weaned her off of her fentanyl, not completely, but enough for me to perform a pain pump trial. She did very well. We implanted the pump, and this lady lived for another 11 years. So don't lose hope.

SPEAKER_00

So starting today, we shift from tools to the people. And there's no better place to start than when the patient Dr. Nyer sees more than almost any other. The patient who had back surgery, sometimes even two or three, was told that it went well, but is still in pain every single day. So it has a name, failed back surgery syndrome. And today we're going to talk about why it happens and why going back under the knife is rarely the answer, and then what the path to recovery actually looks like. So let's continue. Dr. Nyer, failed back surgery syndrome is a term most listeners have never heard of. Yet you see it in your office almost every week. So share with us what it is and how common it is.

SPEAKER_01

Very good. So failed back surgery syndrome, or another name for it is post-laminectomy pain syndrome. This really occurs after a surgical intervention. Let's say a patient has developed a herniated disc, developed sciatica, failed conservative treatment, and injection therapy. And if the orthopedic spine surgeon decides that they want to do a decompression of the nerve root, then they proceed with the surgery. Most often the reason for that is scar tissue formation. So how does that occur? Believe it or not, just like any other part of our body, if we have had surgery, sometimes we can heal pretty well without any problems, but sometimes we can develop scar tissue. And an extreme form of that could be development of keloids. Now that's usually at the skin level. But with failed back surgery syndrome, the surgical technique itself requires removal of a certain part of the spine, and that is called the lamina, hence laminectomy. So the surgeon would first make a small opening in the lamina, which will allow the surgeon to place one of the instruments that he uses to scoop out the disc that's herniated. Now, after the disc has been herniated and the nerve root has been cleared of any debris from the disc, once he removes his equipment or instruments, that lamina, that bone that they had taken out, is not replaced, or it cannot be replaced because you have to make a hole in the lamina. I can show you on this spine model here. This bone in this area here, that's called a lamina, and that's what's taken out. From that point, they insert the instrument to scoop up the herniated disc. Once that process is done, the instrument is removed, but that hole in the lamina still remains. And healing occurs by filling up that area with scar tissue. Sometimes that scar tissue can get attached to the nerve root, and that's why the pain returns sometimes with a vengeance, and you'll have the same pattern of pain because the lamina is located at the same level as which the nerve root is coming from. So these patients can, you know, I hear patients say that for the first three months I did really well, and then all of a sudden the pain came back. It actually takes that amount of time for the scar tissue to build up. Now, fortunately, uh failed back surgery syndrome, you know, in literature they say that it can be anywhere from eight to 20%. But I see a lot of patients who've had back surgery, and hence the number of patients that I see with failed back surgery syndrome is higher. It may be skewed because of the specialty that I'm in, because I see a lot of patients who've had multiple back surgeries and continue to have sciatica. So that is one way that patients can develop pain despite having back surgery.

SPEAKER_00

I see. So back in episode four, you explained us that fixing the anatomy doesn't always fix the pain. So now walk us through like the actual reasons that a patient can have a technically perfect surgery but still be in pain and still hurt.

SPEAKER_01

That's such a great question because I hear my orthopedic colleagues tell me very often that you know they were able to successfully do minimally invasive removal of a herniated disc or a prolapse disc. And uh patient, despite having that successful surgery, still continues to have sciatica. So it's very important to remember that when a patient develops a herniated disc, now one has to take into consideration the extent of the herniation. Now, if a substantially large amount of disc material has entered where the nerve root normally lives, that can cause quite a lot of pressure on the nerve, not to mention the pain, tingling, numbness, and weakness in the leg. Now, many patients will wait for a fairly long period of time before getting surgical intervention. So you may ask, why did they wait? Well, the whole process of getting diagnosed with a herniated disc, getting physical therapy, getting injections, getting to see an orthopedic doctor who then does his evaluation. Maybe they might order an MRI, maybe they might order other tests, maybe an EMG, all of that takes time. And of course, there are some patients who let their pain go on for years before they get any attention to it. What happens over this period of time is that that nerve root, subject to this discernation, starts developing different rewired pain circuits. So, in other words, if let's say the patient eventually gets that obstruction removed, the pain will persist because now there are permanent new circuits that have developed which cause pain. So that's yet another reason why, despite having back surgery, you still have persistent pain. Other reasons could be, you know, damage to the muscles or the ligaments that are holding the uh vertebral body in place can also be a source of pain. Sometimes it's very difficult to differentiate where the pain is coming from and whether the pain is from a different source than what originally occurred with the herniated disc. In addition to that, many patients who have dys herniations end up having their disc height diminish, which causes. Let me pull up my spine model again, it causes the two adjacent bones to move closer to each other. And that will cause the facet joints in the back to engage, and that can cause a fair amount of low back pain. It's important to differentiate between low back pain and pain that radiates down the leg. We did talk about that in an earlier episode. We talked about back pain being called axial back pain or axial pain, and we talked about pain going down the leg as radiculopathy, or commonly otherwise called sciatica. Usually, axial back pain originates from the facet joints. Now, even though when surgeons perform back surgery, they do make every effort to try and ablate the nerves that innervate the facet joint, but it is not always successful. And so that continues to remain a source of pain.

SPEAKER_00

Well, let's talk about the human side now. Uh, describe the patient who walks into your office after two or three back surgeries. What has their life looked like by the time they reach you?

SPEAKER_01

Well, unfortunately, the patient that you just described comes in either taking a lot of pain medication, having lots of pain, disabled, not having work or lost their jobs, and they usually are quite miserable. And I think there's an element of depression, which understandably so, when they're not able to conduct their day-to-day functions, they're not able to spend the time that they want with their loved ones, there will be a sense of doom and gloom that comes over. So that's the type of patient that I see. And, you know, one thing I make it a point is to give the patient an opportunity to express themselves. Let them tell me their journey. And I always try to hear what they have to say. And I do give them enough time to express themselves. Because I think that's part of healing too, because very often I hear my patients say that the doctors that they went to didn't bother giving them enough time to listen, and they'd give them a prescription very quickly. So, you know, I make it a point to spend time, listen to the patient, and you know, I explain to the patient that in addition to having physical pain, there may be a psychological component to it. There may be some anxiety or depression associated with it. And so we try to tease out all of this so that the patient is more aware of what they're dealing with. Subsequent to that, we talk about what are the realistic options for treatment of their pain. Now, let's say this patient, like you said, multiple back surgery, spinal fusion, there has been permanent alteration of the anatomy. And it would be also important for me to express to the patient that the pain that they're they're experiencing is real, and unfortunately, it may be there permanently. The next step would be to say, what are the things that I can do to reduce or ameliorate the pain? Now, in this particular patient's case, if they have been taking uh maximum doses of opioid medication, then I may suggest to them uh options like a pain pump. Now, one may ask the question, well, Doctor, why are you suggesting a pain pump right off the bat? Well, the reason is once you've had multiple back surgeries, I don't think things like physical therapy or muscle relaxants or tens machines or even injections are going to put a dent in the patient's pain. Because at the end of the day, remember, the patient is coming to me not to get 10% or 20% of their pain better. They're looking at a solution to give them better quality of life. And that's why I would at this point suggest a pain pump. And I'll tell the patient, let's do a pain pump trial. Let me deliver a tiny dose of the pain medication to the spinal fluid to see if that'll help your pain. Now, let's say we have a patient, a different patient, multiple back surgeries, but fortunately they may not be on too many pain pills. And if their pain is more sciatica and less axial back pain, then this patient would do very well with a spinal cord stimulator. Now, we also talked about peripheral nerve stimulators for axial low back pain. And I'm seeing quite a lot of success in the last year in peripheral nerve stimulators for low back pain. Unfortunately, a lot of insurance companies are now recognizing the utility of using peripheral nerve stimulators, and they are actually covering this device.

SPEAKER_00

Well, when a patient is hurting, the instinct for the patient, and often perhaps even for the surgeon too, is to let's go back in and fix it. Let's correct the problem. So, why is a second or third surgery so often not the right move?

SPEAKER_01

Well, let's go back to the whole process of scar tissue development. Now, before I answer that question, scar tissue, what it does is that once it fills up that laminotomy scar, it cannot be removed. So any attempt to remove it is only going to create more scar tissue. Now, there are ways that the scar tissue can be diagnosed. There is an MRI that can be done where the patient receives a certain type of dye in their vein. And as a result, the scar tissue will absorb that dye so you can actually see the scar tissue, which then kind of helps you in the diagnosis. And also, that should be an indication that further back surgery should be avoided because the patient may likely develop more scar tissue, causing the patient to have even more pain. So it's my firm belief that if the patient has had a few back surgeries, I don't believe that the answer is to have more back surgeries. I think the patient has to be thoroughly evaluated and given, give the patient treatment options and realistically tell the patient what is likely to help you and what is not that likely to help you.

SPEAKER_00

How soon should someone who is still hurting after their surgery see a pain specialist? Is there a window where the outcomes are better? Is there a sweet spot that you want to shoot for?

SPEAKER_01

Great question. Again, most patients who've had back surgery, they usually will be following up with their surgeon for probably six to eight weeks after the surgery. Now, if in the first six weeks the patient has increased pain, most of my orthopaedic colleagues will do a further evaluation or further testing to see if there is anything wrong with the surgical procedure itself. Assuming that the surgery went well and the patient continues to have increased pain, I hear a lot of patients say that their uh surgeons told them that they'd have to wait up to 18 months to see pain relief. But in my opinion, if the patient isn't getting any relief within three to four months after having surgery, then at least from the pain perspective, that surgery has not been able to achieve its goal. Now, the surgery may have structurally corrected the patient's spine, but uh most patients don't go and see their spinal surgeon to get structural improvement in their spine. They go there to get their pain under control. And so I would say give it three to four months. If you don't see an improvement in pain or if the pain has gotten worse, they definitely need to seek advice to see if something has either if there's a particular reason why the pain has gotten worse. So further evaluation is necessary. And at that point, the patient should be offered other treatment options for their pain.

SPEAKER_00

Good to know. Good to know. All right, so that three to four month mark is crucial to see, evaluate where you're at post-surgery. Um, I'm sure there's a listener, Dr. Nyer, right now, who's had back surgery, who's still in pain, and perhaps has been told that there's nothing more to be done. Um, what would you say to that person if they're feeling defeated or uh, you know, still in pain, but everything structurally okay?

SPEAKER_01

Well, first thing that I would tell them is do not lose hope. That is so important because if you've lost hope and if you're going down that rabbit hole, even if there was a cure that would make your pain go away, you know, it wouldn't be as simple as just make just hey, presto, it's gone away. They still have to deal with feeling low, feeling depressed. So, first thing is do not lose hope. Second thing is with chronic pain, whether it's multiple back surgeries or any type of catastrophic injury, the greatest thing is we have the ability to deliver pain medication directly to where the source of the pain is. So, therefore, there is no reason to not be hopeful. Now, I will say this though, I've seen a good number of patients who have had multiple surgeries and they're taking extremely high doses of oral narcotics. Patients may be on high doses of morphine, high doses of oxycontin, or the fentanyl patch. Now, those types of patients are going to be a little bit more challenging because even for a pain pump to work for them, we would have to slowly taper the oral drugs down to a safer level, which will then allow me to do a pain pump trial. Because if their oral medications are sky high, there's no amount of medicine that I can deliver into the spinal fluid that will contain their pain. So I would have to educate the patient. If a patient is taking the high doses of oral opioid medications, um, what I would say to them is we would need to try and slowly taper the medication down. I wouldn't say down to zero, but sufficient enough to allow me to do a pain pump trial to deliver the narcotic directly into the spinal fluid. In contrast, if let's say a patient's taking a high dose of oral pain medication, let's say they're taking oxycontin, 80 milligrams three or four times a day, the oral dose of the pain medication is so high that even if I were to give the patient a dose of pain medication directly into the spinal fluid, it would not make an impact or a dent in their pain. So, therefore, it is very important to taper the medicine downwards and then perform a pain pump trial and see if that contains their pain better. And if it does, then the patient should go for a pain pump implant at that point. So, in other words, my point is that there is really no injury that's so significant that there is no remedy. Because I I remember um treating a 91-year-old patient who had six back surgeries, and she was taking a bucket load of fentanyl. Um, and despite that, she had chronic intractable pain. Well, just like I told you earlier on, we weaned her off of her fentanyl, uh, not completely, but enough for me to perform a pain pump trial. She did very well. We implanted the pump, and this lady lived for another 11 years. So, you know, I've seen many, many patients who have, you know, very similar stories, multiple back surgeries or catastrophic injuries, uh, who are suffering from chronic pain. But, you know, the first thing is don't lose hope.

SPEAKER_00

Tell us now to close out today's episode. How does treating failed back surgery syndrome fit into your bigger mission, which is lowering pill use and avoiding unnecessary surgeries in Kentucky?

SPEAKER_01

That's a complex question, but I believe that patients who have been suffering from chronic pain and who have been taking a fair amount of pain medication. I'm not against patients taking pain medication. I'm just offering patients an alternative because consuming fewer pain pills will clear up your meditation and you'll be more alert and focused on taking care of your pain, doing exercises, stretching exercises, and other ways that can help improve the patient's well-being. Now, interventions, pain management interventions like pain palms, spinal cord stimulators, and peripheral nerve stimulators, all of those are great and dandy, but the patient has to be mentally prepared also. That they also need to be prepared that maybe their pain's not going to go down to zero, but with the interventions that I can offer, that pain can be managed. And with that tighter control of pain, they may be able to do more things, take part in more of their day-to-day activities, and overall have a better quality of life.

SPEAKER_00

Fantastic. Well, to our listeners, thank you for joining us for episode 11 of the Kentucky Pain Reversal Show. Today's biggest takeaway is that a surgery can be a technical success, but still leave you in pain. And that does not mean that you're out of options. It simply means that the pain needs a different kind of answer and a different kind of doctor. So if you've had back surgery and you still hurt, you're not imagining it, you're not a failure, and you are not stuck, most importantly. There is a path forward, and that's right here in Kentucky. Lower the pills, lower the surgeries, and stop the pain. We'll see you next time in episode 12.